Healthcare analytics, AI solutions for biological big data, providing an AI platform for the biotech, life sciences, medical and pharmaceutical industries, as well as for related technological approaches, i.e., curation and text analysis with machine learning and other activities related to AI applications to these industries.
This article is a look at where the biomedical research sciences are in developing standards for development in the near term.
Let’s Not Wait for the FDA: Raising the Standards of Biomarker Development – A New Series
published by Theral Timpson on Tue, 07/01/2014 – 15:03
We talk a lot on this show about the potential of personalized medicine. Never before have we learned at such breakneck speed just how our bodies function. The pace of biological research staggers the mind and hints at a time when we will “crack the code” of the system that is homo sapiens, going from picking the low hanging fruit to a more rational approach. The high tech world has put at the fingertips of biologists just the tools to do it. There is plenty of compute, plenty of storage available to untangle, or decipher the human body. Yet still, we talk of potential.
Chat with anyone heavily involved in the life science industry–be it diagnostics or pharma– and you’ll quickly hear that we must have better biomarkers.
Next week we launch a series, Let’s Not Wait for the FDA: Raising the Standards of Biomarker Development, where we will pursue the “hotspots” that are haunting those in the field.
The National Biomarker Development Alliance (NBDA) is a non profit organization based at Arizona State University and led by the formidable Anna Barker, former deputy director of the NCI. The aim of the NBDA is to identify problem areas in biomarker development–from the biospecimen and sampling issues to experiment design to bioinformatics challenges–and raise the standards in each area. This series of interviews is based on their approach. We will purse each of these topics with a special guest.
The place to start is with samples. The majority of researchers who are working on biomarker assays don’t give much thought to the “story” of their samples. Yet the quality of their research will never exceed the quality of the samples with which they start–a very scary thought according toCarolyn Compton, a former pathologist, now professor of pathology at ASU and Johns Hopkins. Carolyn worked originally as a clinical pathologist and knows first hand the the issues around sample degradation. She left the clinic when she was recruited to the NCI with the mission of bringing more awareness to the issue of bio specimens. She joins us as our first guest in the series.
That Carolyn has straddled the world of the clinic and the world of research is key to her message. And it’s key to this series. As we see an increased push to “translate” research into clinical applications, we find that these two worlds do not work enough together.
Researchers spend a lot of time analyzing data and developing causal relationships from certain biological molecules to a disease. But how often do these researchers consider how the history of a sample might be altering their data?
“Garbage in, garbage out,” says Carolyn, who links low quality samples with the abysmal non-reproducable rate of most published research.
Two of our guests in the series have worked on the adaptive iSpy breast cancer trials. These are innovative clinical trials that have been designed to “adapt” to the specific biology of those in the trial. Using the latest advances in genetics, the iSPY trials aim to match experimental drugs with the molecular makeup of tumors most likely to respond to them. And the trials are testing multiple drugs at once.
Don Berry is known for bringing statistics to clinical trials. He designed the iSpy trials and joins us to explain how these new trials work and of the promise of the adaptive design.
Laura Esserman is the director of the breast cancer center at UCSC and has been heavily involved in the implementation of the iSpy trials. Esserman is concerned that “if we keep doing conventional clinical trials, people are going to give up on doing them.” An MBA as well as an MD, Esserman brings what she learned about innovation in the high-tech industry to treatment for breast cancer.
From there we turn to the topic of “systems biology” where we will chat with George Poste, a tour de force when it comes to considering all of the various aspects of biology. Anyone who has ever been present for one of George’s presentations has no doubt come away scratching your head wondering if we’ll ever really glimpse the whole system that is a human being. If there is one brain that has seen all the rooms and hallways of our complex system, it’s George Poste.
We’ll finish the series by interviewing David Haussler from UCSC of Genome Browser fame. Recently Haussler has worked extensively on an NCI project, The Cancer Genome Atlas, to bring together data sets and connect cancer researchers around the world. What is the promise and pitfalls David sees with the latest bioinformatics tools?
George Poste says that in the literature we have identified 150,000 biomarkers that have causal linkage to disease. Yet only 100 of these have been commercialized and are used in the clinic. Why is the number so low? We hope to come up with some answers in this series.
Why Hasn’t Clinical Genetics Taken Off? (part 2)
published by Sultan Meghji on Fri, 06/20/2014 – 14:49
In my previous post, I made the broad comment that education of the patient and front line doctors was the single largest barrier to entry for clinical genetics. Here I look at the steps in the scientific process and where the biggest opportunities lie:
The Sequencing (still)
PCR is a perfectly reasonable technology for sequencing in the research lab today, but the current configuration of technologies need to change. We need to move away from an expert level skill set and a complicated chemistry process in the lab to a disposable, consumer friendly set of technologies. I’m not convinced PCR is the right technology for that and would love to see nanopore be a serious contender, but lack of funding for a broad spectrum of both physics-only as well as physical-electrical startups have slowed the progress of these technologies. And waiting in the wings, other technologies are spinning up in research labs around the world. Price is no longer a serious problem in the space – reliable, repeatable, easy to use sequencing technologies are. The complexity of the current technology (both in terms of sample preparation and machine operation) is a big hurdle.
The Analysis (compute)
Over the last few years, quite a bit of commentary and effort has been put into making the case that the compute is a significant challenge (including more than a few comments by yours truly in that vein!). Today, it can be said with total confidence that compute is NOT a problem. Compute has been commoditized. Through excellent new software to advanced platforms and new hardware, it is a trivial exercise to do the analysis and costs tiny amounts of money ($<25 per sample on a cloud provider appears to be the going rate for a clinical exome in terms of platform & infrastructure cost). Integration with the sequencer and downstream medical middleware is the biggest opportunity.
The Analysis (value)
The bigger challenge on the analysis is the specific things being analyzed as mapped to the needs of the patient. We are still in a world where the vast majority of the sequencing work is being done in support of a specific patient with a specific disease. There isn’t even broad consensus yet in the scientific community about the basics of the pipeline (see my blog posthere for an attempt at capturing what I’m seeing in the market). A movement away from the recent trend in studying specific indications (esp. cancer) is called for. Broadening the sample population will allow us to pick simpler, clearer and easier pipelines which will then make them more adoptable. It would be a massive benefit to the world if the scientific, medical and regulatory communities would get together and start creating, in a crowdsourced manner, a small number of databases that are specifically useful to healthy people. Targeting things like nutrition, athletics, metabolism, and other normal aspects of daily life. A dataset that could, when any one person’s DNA is references, would find something useful. Including the regulators is key so that we can begin to move away from the old fashioned model of clearances that still permeate the industry.
The Regulators
Beyond the broader issues around education I referenced in my previous post, there is a massive upgrade in the regulation infrastructure that is needed. We still live in a world of fax machines, overnight shipping of paper documents and personal relationships all being more important than the quality of the science you as an innovator are bringing to bear.
Consider the recent massive growth in wearables, fitness trackers and other instrumentation local to the human body. Why must we treat clinical genetics simply as a diagnostic and not, as it should be, as a fundamental set of quantitative data about your body that you can leverage in a myriad of ways. Direct to consumer (DTC) genetics companies, most notably 23andme, have approached this problem poorly – instead of making it valuable to the average consumer, what they’ve done is attempted to straddle the line between medical and not. The Fitbit model has shown very clearly that lifestyle activities can be directly harnessed to build commercial value in scaling health related activities without becoming a regulatory issue. It’s time for genetics to do the same thing.
A few weeks back, we published a review about the development and role of the human reference genome. A key point of the reference genome is that it is not a single sequence. Instead it is an assembly of consensus sequences that are designed to deal with variation in the human population and uncertainty in the data. The reference is a map and like a geographical maps evolves though increased understanding over time.
From the Wiley On Line site:
Abstract
Genome maps, like geographical maps, need to be interpreted carefully. Although maps are essential to exploration and navigation they cannot be completely accurate. Humans have been mapping the world for several millennia, but genomes have been mapped and explored for just a single century with the greatest advancements in making a sequence reference map of the human genome possible in the past 30 years. After the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) sequence of the human genome was completed in 2003, the reference sequence underwent several improvements and today provides the underlying comparative resource for a multitude genetic assays and biochemical measurements. However, the ability to simplify genetic analysis through a single comprehensive map remains an elusive goal.
Key Concepts:
Maps are incomplete and contain errors.
DNA sequence data are interpreted through biochemical experiments or comparisons to other DNA sequences.
A reference genome sequence is a map that provides the essential coordinate system for annotating the functional regions of the genome and comparing differences between individuals’ genomes.
The reference genome sequence is always product of understanding at a set point in time and continues to evolve.
DNA sequences evolve through duplication and mutation and, as a result, contain many repeated sequences of different sizes, which complicates data analysis.
DNA sequence variation happens on large and small scales with respect to the lengths of the DNA differences to include single base changes, insertions, deletions, duplications and rearrangements.
DNA sequences within the human population undergo continual change and vary highly between individuals.
The current reference genome sequence is a collection of sequences, an assembly, that include sequences assembled into chromosomes, sequences that are part of structurally complex regions that cannot be assembled, patches (fixes) that cannot be included in the primary sequence, and high variability sequences that are organised into alternate loci.
Genetic analysis is error prone and the data require validation because the methods for collecting DNA sequences create artifacts and the reference sequence used for comparative analyses is incomplete.
I came across a few recent articles on the subject of US Patent Office guidance on patentability as well as on Supreme Court ruling on claims. I filed several patents on clinical laboratory methods early in my career upon the recommendation of my brother-in-law, now deceased. Years later, after both brother-in-law and patent attorney are no longer alive, I look back and ask what I have learned over $100,000 later, with many trips to the USPTO, opportunities not taken, and a one year provisional patent behind me.
My conclusion is
(1) that patents are for the protection of the innovator, who might realize legal protection, but the cost and the time investment can well exceed the cost of startup and building a small startup enterprize, that would be the next step.
(2) The other thing to consider is the capability of the lawyer or firm that represents you. A patent that is well done can be expected to take 5-7 years to go through with due diligence. I would not expect it to be done well by a university with many other competing demands. I might be wrong in this respect, as the climate has changed, and research universities have sprouted engines for change. Experienced and productive faculty are encouraged or allowed to form their own such entities.
(3) The emergence of Big Data, computational biology, and very large data warehouses for data use and integration has changed the landscape. The resources required for an individual to pursue research along these lines is quite beyond an individuals sole capacity to successfully pursue without outside funding. In addition, the changed designated requirement of first to publish has muddied the water.
Of course, one can propose without anything published in the public domain. That makes it possible for corporate entities to file thousands of patents, whether there is actual validation or not at the time of filing. It would be a quite trying experience for anyone to pursue in the USPTO without some litigation over ownership of patent rights. At this stage of of technology development, I have come to realize that the organization of research, peer review, and archiving of data is still at a stage where some of the best systems avalailable for storing and accessing data still comes considerably short of what is needed for the most complex tasks, even though improvements have come at an exponential pace.
I shall not comment on the contested views held by physicists, chemists, biologists, and economists over the completeness of guiding theories strongly held. Only history will tell. Beliefs can hold a strong sway, and have many times held us back.
I am not an expert on legal matters, but it is incomprehensible to me that issues concerning technology innovation can be adjudicated in the Supreme Court, as has occurred in recent years. I have postgraduate degrees in Medicine, Developmental Anatomy, and post-medical training in pathology and laboratory medicine, as well as experience in analytical and research biochemistry. It is beyond the competencies expected for these type of cases to come before the Supreme Court, or even to the Federal District Courts, as we see with increasing frequency, as this has occurred with respect to the development and application of the human genome.
I’m not sure that the developments can be resolved for the public good without a more full development of an open-access system of publishing. Now I present some recent publication about, or published by the USPTO.
DR ANTHONY MELVIN CRASTO
Dr. Melvin Castro – Organic Chemistry and New Drug Development
YOU ARE FOLLOWING THIS BLOG You are following this blog, along with 1,014 other amazing people (manage).
USPTO Guidance On Patentable Subject Matter: Impediment to Biotech Innovation
Joanna T. Brougher, David A. FazzolareJ Commercial Biotechnology 2014 20(3):Brougher
jcbiotech-patents
Abstract In June 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a unanimous decision upending more than three decades worth of established patent practice when it ruled that isolated gene sequences are no longer patentable subject matter under 35 U.S.C. Section 101.While many practitioners in the field believed that the USPTO would interpret the decision narrowly, the USPTO actually expanded the scope of the decision when it issued its guidelines for determining whether an invention satisfies Section 101.
The guidelines were met with intense backlash with many arguing that they unnecessarily expanded the scope of the Supreme Court cases in a way that could unduly restrict the scope of patentable subject matter, weaken the U.S. patent system, and create a disincentive to innovation. By undermining patentable subject matter in this way, the guidelines may end up harming not only the companies that patent medical innovations, but also the patients who need medical care. This article examines the guidelines and their impact on various technologies.
35 U.S.C. Section 101 states “Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
” Prometheus Laboratories, Inc. v. Mayo Collaborative Services, 566 U.S. ___ (2012)
Association for Molecular Pathology et al., v. Myriad Genetics, Inc., 569 U.S. ___ (2013).
Parke-Davis & Co. v. H.K. Mulford Co., 189 F. 95, 103 (C.C.S.D.N.Y. 1911)
USPTO. Guidance For Determining Subject Matter Eligibility Of Claims Reciting Or Involving Laws of Nature, Natural Phenomena, & Natural Products.
A 2013 Supreme Court decision that barred human gene patents is scrambling patenting policies.
PHOTO: MLADEN ANTONOV/AFP/GETTY IMAGES
A year after the U.S. Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling that human genes cannot be patented, the biotech industry is struggling to adapt to a landscape in which inventions derived from nature are increasingly hard to patent. It is also pushing back against follow-on policies proposed by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) to guide examiners deciding whether an invention is too close to a natural product to deserve patent protection. Those policies reach far beyond what the high court intended, biotech representatives say.
“Everything we took for granted a few years ago is now changing, and it’s generating a bit of a scramble,” says patent attorney Damian Kotsis of Harness Dickey in Troy, Michigan, one of more than 15,000 people who gathered here last week for the Biotechnology Industry Organization’s (BIO’s) International Convention.
At the meeting, attorneys and executives fretted over the fate of patent applications for inventions involving naturally occurring products—including chemical compounds, antibodies, seeds, and vaccines—and traded stories of recent, unexpected rejections by USPTO. Industry leaders warned that the uncertainty could chill efforts to commercialize scientific discoveries made at universities and companies. Some plan to appeal the rejections in federal court.
USPTO officials, meanwhile, implored attendees to send them suggestions on how to clarify and improve its new policies on patenting natural products, and even announced that they were extending the deadline for public comment by a month. “Each and every one of you in this room has a moral duty … to provide written comments to the PTO,” patent lawyer and former USPTO Deputy Director Teresa Stanek Rea told one audience.
At the heart of the shake-up are two Supreme Court decisions: the ruling last year in Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics Inc. that human genes cannot be patented because they occur naturally (Science, 21 June 2013, p. 1387); and the 2012 Mayo v. Prometheus decision, which invalidated a patent on a method of measuring blood metabolites to determine drug doses because it relied on a “law of nature” (Science, 12 July 2013, p. 137).
Myriad and Mayo are already having a noticeable impact on patent decisions, according to a study released here. It examined about 1000 patent applications that included claims linked to natural products or laws of nature that USPTO reviewed between April 2011 and March 2014. Overall, examiners rejected about 40%; Myriad was the basis for rejecting about 23% of the applications, and Mayo about 35%, with some overlap, the authors concluded. That rejection rate would have been in the single digits just 5 years ago, asserted Hans Sauer, BIO’s intellectual property counsel, at a press conference. (There are no historical numbers for comparison.) The study was conducted by the news service Bloomberg BNA and the law firm Robins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciseri in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
USPTO is extending the decisions far beyond diagnostics and DNA?
The numbers suggest USPTO is extending the decisions far beyond diagnostics and DNA, attorneys say. Harness Dickey’s Kotsis, for example, says a client recently tried to patent a plant extract with therapeutic properties; it was different from anything in nature, Kotsis argued, because the inventor had altered the relative concentrations of key compounds to enhance its effect. Nope, decided USPTO, too close to nature.
In March, USPTO released draft guidance designed to help its examiners decide such questions, setting out 12 factors for them to weigh. For example, if an examiner deems a product “markedly different in structure” from anything in nature, that counts in its favor. But if it has a “high level of generality,” it gets dinged.
The draft has drawn extensive criticism. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen anything as complicated as this,” says Kevin Bastian, a patent attorney at Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton in San Francisco, California. “I just can’t believe that this will be the standard.”
USPTO officials appear eager to fine-tune the draft guidance, but patent experts fear the Supreme Court decisions have made it hard to draw clear lines. “The Myriad decision is hopelessly contradictory and completely incoherent,” says Dan Burk, a law professor at the University of California, Irvine. “We know you can’t patent genetic sequences,” he adds, but “we don’t really know why.”
Get creative in using Draft Guidelines!
For now, Kostis says, applicants will have to get creative to reduce the chance of rejection. Rather than claim protection for a plant extract itself, for instance, an inventor could instead patent the steps for using it to treat patients. Other biotech attorneys may try to narrow their patent claims. But there’s a downside to that strategy, they note: Narrower patents can be harder to protect from infringement, making them less attractive to investors. Others plan to wait out the storm, predicting USPTO will ultimately rethink its guidance and ease the way for new patents.
Public comment period extended
USPTO has extended the deadline for public comment to 31 July, with no schedule for issuing final language. Regardless of the outcome, however, Stanek Rea warned a crowd of riled-up attorneys that, in the world of biopatents, “the easy days are gone.”
Manual of Patent Examining Procedure (MPEP)Ninth Edition, March 2014
The USPTO continues to offer an online discussion tool for commenting on selected chapters of the Manual. To participate in the discussion and to contribute your ideas go to: http://uspto-mpep.ideascale.com.
Manual of Patent Examining Procedure (MPEP)Ninth Edition, March 2014
The USPTO continues to offer an online discussion tool for commenting on selected chapters of the Manual. To participate in the discussion and to contribute your ideas go to:http://uspto-mpep.ideascale.com.
The documents updated in the Ninth Edition of the MPEP, dated March 2014, include changes that became effective in November 2013 or earlier.
All of the documents have been updated for the Ninth Edition except Chapters 800, 900, 1000, 1300, 1700, 1800, 1900, 2000, 2300, 2400, 2500, and Appendix P.
More information about the changes and updates is available from the “Blue Page – Introduction” of the Searchable MPEP or from the “Summary of Changes” link to the HTML and PDF versions provided below. Discuss the Manual of Patent Examining Procedure (MPEP) Welcome to the MPEP discussion tool!
We have received many thoughtful ideas on Chapters 100-600 and 1800 of the MPEP as well as on how to improve the discussion site. Each and every idea submitted by you, the participants in this conversation, has been carefully reviewed by the Office, and many of these ideas have been implemented in the August 2012 revision of the MPEP and many will be implemented in future revisions of the MPEP. The August 2012 revision is the first version provided to the public in a web based searchable format. The new search tool is available at http://mpep.uspto.gov. We would like to thank everyone for participating in the discussion of the MPEP.
We have some great news! Chapters 1300, 1500, 1600 and 2400 of the MPEP are now available for discussion. Please submit any ideas and comments you may have on these chapters. Also, don’t forget to vote on ideas and comments submitted by other users. As before, our editorial staff will periodically be posting proposed new material for you to respond to, and in some cases will post responses to some of the submitted ideas and comments.Recently, we have received several comments concerning the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA). Please note that comments regarding the implementation of the AIA should be submitted to the USPTO via email t aia_implementation@uspto.gov or via postal mail, as indicated at the America Invents Act Web site. Additional information regarding the AIA is available at www.uspto.gov/americainventsact We have also received several comments suggesting policy changes which have been routed to the appropriate offices for consideration. We really appreciate your thinking and recommendations!
After more than 5 years and two draft versions, the final version of the Guidance for
Industry (GfI) – “Electronic Source Data in Clinical Investigations” was published in
September 2013. This new FDA Guidance defines the FDA’s expectations for sponsors,
CROs, investigators and other persons involved in the capture, review and retention of
electronic source data generated in the context of FDA-regulated clinical trials.In an
effort to encourage the modernization and increased efficiency of processes in clinical
trials, the FDA clearly supports the capture of electronic source data and emphasizes
the agency’s intention to support activities aimed at ensuring the reliability, quality,
integrity and traceability of this source data, from its electronic source to the electronic
submission of the data in the context of an authorization procedure. The Guidance
addresses aspects as data capture, data review and record retention. When the
computerized systems used in clinical trials are described, the FDA recommends
that the description not only focus on the intended use of the system, but also on
data protection measures and the flow of data across system components and
interfaces. In practice, the pharmaceutical industry needs to meet significant
requirements regarding organisation, planning, specification and verification of
computerized systems in the field of clinical trials. The FDA also mentions in the
Guidance that it does not intend to apply 21 CFR Part 11 to electronic health records
(EHR). Author: Oliver Herrmann Q-Infiity Source: http://www.fda.gov/downloads/Drugs/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/
Guidances/UCM328691.pdf Webinar: https://collaboration.fda.gov/p89r92dh8wc
John Carroll reports on a disappointing ruling by the FDA on AstraZeneca’s PARP1 inhibitor olaparib for maintenance therapy in women with cisplatin refractory ovarian cancer with BRCA mutation. Early clinical investigations had pointed to efficacy of PARP inhibitors in ovarian tumors carrying the BRCA mutation. The scientific rationale for using PARP1 inhibitors in BRCA1/2 deficiency was quite clear:
DNA damage can result in
1. double strand breaks (DSB)
DSB can be repaired by efficient homologous recombination (HR) or less efficient non-homologous end joining (NHEJ)
b. BRCA1 involved in RAD51 dependent HR at DSB sites
In BRCA1 deficiency DSB repaired by less efficient NHEJ
2. single strand breaks, damage (SSB)
PARP1 is activated by DNA damage and poly-ADP ribosylates histones and other proteins marking DNA for SSB repair
SSB repair usually base excision (BER) or sometimes nucleotide excision repair (NER)
B. if PARP inhibited then SSB gets converted to DSB
C. in BRCA1/2 deficient background repair is forced to less efficient NHEJ thereby perpetuating some DNA damage pon exposure to DNA damaging agent
(from Christina M Annunziata and Susan E Bates. PARP inhibitors in BRCA1/BRCA2 germline mutation carriers with ovarian and breast cancer. F1000 Biol Reports, 2010; 2:10.) Creative Commons
Dana Farber’s Dr. Ralph Scully, Ph.D., in Exploiting DNA Repair Targets in Breast Cancer (http://www.dfhcc.harvard.edu/news/news/article/5402/), explains his research investigating why multiple DNA repair pathways may have to be targeted with PARP therapy concurrent with BRCA1 deficiency.
However FDA investigators voiced their skepticism of AstraZeneca’s clinical results, namely
Small number of patients enrolled
BRCA1/2 cohort were identified retrospectively
results skewed by false benefit from “underperforming” control arm
possible inadvertent selection bias
hazard ratio suggesting improvement in progression free survival but higher risk/benefit
The FDA investigators released their report two days before an expert panel would be releasing their own report (reported in the link below from FierceBiotech)
in which the expert panel reiterated the findings of the FDA investigators. The expert panel’s job was to find if there was any clinical benefit for continuing consideration of olaparib, basically stating
“This trial has problems,” noted FDA cancer chief Richard Pazdur during the panel discussion. If investigators had “pristine evidence of a 7-month advantage in PFS, we wouldn’t be here.”
The expert panel was concerned for the above reasons as well as the reported handful of lethal cases of myelodysplastic syndrome and acute myeloid leukemia in the study, although the panel noted these patients had advanced disease before entering the trial, raising the possibility that prior drugs may have triggered their deaths.
This was certainly a disappointment as ….
it was at last year’s ASCO (2013) that investigators at Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania and Sheba Medical Center in Tel Hashomer, Israel presented data showing that in 193 cisplatin-refractory ovarian cancer patients carrying a BRCA1/2 mutation, 31% had a partial or complete tumor regression. In addition the study also showed good response in pancreatic and prostate cancer with tolerable side effects.
As John Carrol from FierceBiotech notes, the decision may spark renewed interest by Pfizer of a bid for AstraZeneca as the potential FDA rejection would certainly dampen AstraZeneca’s future growth and profit plans. Last month AstraZeneca’s CEO made the case to shareholders to reject the Pfizer offer by pointing to AstraZeneca’s potential beefed-up pipeline. AstraZeneca had projected olaparib as a potential $2 billion-a-year seller, although some industry analysts see sales at less than half that amount.
A company spokeswoman said the monotherapy use of olaparib for ovarian cancer assessed by the U.S. expert panel this week was only one element of a broad development program.
Please see a table of current oncology clinical trials with PARP1 inhibitors
at end of this post
However, on the same day, FierceBiotechreports some great news (at least in Europe) on the ovarian cancer front:
EU Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) handed down a positive ruling on Avastin, recommending that the European Commission approve the drug for use in women with ovarian cancer that’s resistant to platinum-based chemotherapy. It’s the first biologic to receive a positive opinion from the CHMP for this hard-to-treat form of the disease.
EU had been getting pressure from British doctors to approve Avastin based on clinical trial results although it may be important to note that the EU zone seems to have an ability to recruit more numbers for clinical trials than in US. For instance an EU women’s breast cancer prevention trial had heavy recruitment in what would be considered a short time frame compared to recruitment times for the US.
Below is a table on PARP1 inhibitors in current clinical trials (obtained from NewMedicine’s Oncology KnowledgeBase™). nm|OK is a relational knowledgeBASE covering all major aspects of product development in oncolology. The database comprises 6 modules each dedicated in a specific sector within the oncology field.
PARP1 Inhibitors Currently in Clinical Trials for Ovarian Cancer
Phase I (begin 5/11, ongoing 2/14) Europe (Netherlands)– solid tumors with BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations, locally advanced or metastatic • ovarian cancer, advanced or metastatic • fallopian tube cancer, advanced or metastatic • peritoneal cancer, advanced or metastatic
AstraZeneca Affiliate(s):
· Myriad GeneticsCurrent as of: June 26, 2014Generic Name: Olaparib Brand Name: Lynparza Other Designation: AZD2281, KU59436, KU-0059436, NSC 747856
Phase I (begin 7/05, closed 9/08) Europe (Netherlands, UK, Poland); phase II (begin 6/07, closed 2/08, completed 5/09) USA, Australia, Europe (Germany, Spain, Sweden, UK), phase II (begin 7/08, closed 2/09) USA, Australia, Europe (Belgium, Germany, Poland, Spain, UK), Israel, phase II (begin 8/08, closed 12/09, completed 3/13) USA, Australia, Canada, Europe (Belgium, France, Germany, Poland, Romania, Spain, Ukraine, UK), Israel, Russia; phase II (begin 2/10, closed 7/10) USA, Australia, Canada, Europe (Belgium, Czech Republic, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Spain, UK), Japan, Panama, Peru (combination); MAA (accepted 9/13) EU, NDA (filed 2/14) USA– ovarian cancer, advanced or metastatic, BRCA positive • ovarian cancer, recurrent, platinum sensitive • ovarian cancer, advanced, refractory, BRCA1 or BRCA2-associatedPhase I (begin 5/08, ongoing 5/12) USA; phase II (begin 7/08, closed 10/09) Canada– breast cancer, locally advanced, BRCA1/BRCA2-associated or hereditary metastatic or inoperable • ovarian cancer, locally advanced, BRCA1/BRCA2-associated or hereditary metastatic or inoperable • breast cancer, triple-negative, BRCA-positive • ovarian cancer, high-grade serous and/or undifferentiated, BRCA-positive
Phase I (begin 10/10, ongoing 1/13) USA (combination)– ovarian cancer, inoperable or metastatic, refractory • breast cancer, inoperable or metastatic, refractory
Phase III (begin 8/13) USA, Australia, Brazil, Canada, Europe (France, Italy, Netherlands, Poland, Russia, Spain, UK), Israel, South Korea, phase III (begin 9/13) USA, Australia, Brazil, Canada, Europe (France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Poland, Russia, Spain, UK), Israel– ovarian cancer, serous, high grade, BRCA mutated, platinum-sensitive, relapsed, third line, maintenance • ovarian cancer, serous or endometrioid, high grade, BRCA mutated, platinum responsive (PR or CR), maintenance, first line • primary peritoneal cancer, high grade, BRCA mutated, platinum responsive (PR or CR), maintenance • fallopian tube cancer, high grade, BRCA mutated, platinum responsive (PR or
Clovis Oncology Affiliate(s):
· University of Newcastle Upon Tyne
· Cancer Research Campaign Technology
· PfizerCurrent as of: June 21, 2014Generic Name: Rucaparib Brand Name: Rucapanc Other Designation: AG140699, AG014699, AG-14,699, AG-14669, AG14699, AG140361, AG-14361, AG-014699, CO-338, PF-01367338
Phase I (begin 03, completed 05) Europe (UK) (combination), phase I (begin 2/10, closed 11/13) Europe (France, UK) (combination)– solid tumors, advanced
Phase II (begin 12/07, closed 10/13) Europe (UK)– breast cancer, advanced or metastatic, in patients carrying BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations • ovarian cancer, advanced or metastatic, in patients carrying BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations
Phase I/II (begin 11/11, ongoing 6/14) USA, Europe (UK)– solid tumors, metastatic, with mutated BRCA • breast cancer, metastatic, HEr2 negative, with mutated BRCA
Phase I (begin 5/11, closed 11/12, terminated 10/13) USA, phase I (begin 6/09, closed 7/12, completed 1/12) Europe (France and UK) (combination)– solid tumors, advanced, third line Phase I (begin 5/11, completed 1/13) Europe (France) (combination)– solid tumors, advanced • mantle cell lymphoma (MCL), advanced
Summary of Combination Ovarian Cancer Trials with Avastin (current and closed)
Indication in Development
ovarian cancer, advanced, recurrent, persistent • ovarian cancer, progressive, platinum resistant, second line • fallopian tube cancer, progressive, platinum resistant, second line • primary peritoneal cancer, progressive, platinum resistant, second line
Latest Status
Phase II (begin 4/02, closed 8/04) USA, phase II (begin 11/04, closed 10/05) USA; phase III (begin 10/09) Europe (Belgium, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden), Turkey
Clinical History
Refer to the Combination Trial Module for trials of Avastin in combination with various chemotherapeutic regimens.According to results from the AURELIA clinical trial (protocol ID: MO22224; 2009-011400-33; NCT00976911), the median PFS in women with progressive platinum resistant ovarian, fallopian tube or primary peritoneal cancer treated with Avastin in combination with chemotherapy, was 6.7 months compared to 3.4 months in those treated with chemotherapy alone for an HR of 0.48 (range =0.38–0.60).. In addition, the objective response rate was 30.9% in women treated with Avastin compared to 12.6% in those on chemotherapy (p=0.001). Certain AE (Grade 2 to 5) that occurred more often in the Avastin arm compared to the chemotherapy alone arm were high blood pressure (20% versus 7%) and an excess of protein in the urine (11% versus 1%). Gastrointestinal perforations and fistulas occurred in 2% of women in the Avastin arm compared to no events in the chemotherapy arm (Pujade-Lauraine E, etal, ASCO12, Abs. LBA5002).A multicenter (n=124), randomized, open label, 2-arm, phase III clinical trial (protocol ID: MO22224; 2009-011400-33; NCT00976911; http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/results?term=NCT00976911 ), dubbed AURELIA, was initiated in October 2009, in Europe (Belgium, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, and Sweden), and Turkey, to evaluate the efficacy and safety of Avastin added to chemotherapy versus chemotherapy alone in patients with epithelial ovarian, fallopian tube or primary peritoneal cancer with disease progression within 6 months of platinum therapy in the first line setting. The trials primary outcome measure is PFS. Secondary outcome measures include objective response rate, biological PFS interval, OS, QoL, and safety and tolerability. According to the protocol, all patients are treated with standard chemotherapy with IV paclitaxel (80 mg/m²) on days 1, 8, 15 and 22 of each 4-week cycle; or IV topotecan at a dose of 4 mg/m² on days 1, 8 and 15 of each 4-week cycle, or 1.25 mg/kg on days 1-5 of each 3-week cycle; or IV liposomal doxorubicin (40 mg/m²) every 4 weeks. Patients (n=179) randomized to arm 2 of the trial are treated with IV Avastin at a dose of 10 mg/kg twice weekly or 15 mg/kg thrice weekly concomitantly with the chemotherapy choice. Treatment continues until disease progression. Subsequently, patients are treated with the standard of care. Patients in arm 1 (n=182), on chemotherapy only may opt to be treated with IV Avastin (15 mg/kg) three times weekly. The trial was set up in cooperation with the Group d’Investigateurs Nationaux pour l’Etude des Cancers Ovariens (GINECO) and was conducted by the international network of the Gynecologic Cancer Intergroup (GCIG) and the pan-European Network of Gynaecological Oncological Trial Groups (ENGOT), under PI Eric Pujade-Lauraine, MD, Hopitaux Universitaires, Paris Centre, Hôpital Hôtel-Dieu (Paris, France). The trial enrolled 361 patients and was closed as of May 2012..Results were presented from a phase II clinical trial (protocol ID: CDR0000068839; GOG-0170D; NCT00022659) of bevacizumab in patients with persistent or recurrent epithelial ovarian cancer or primary peritoneal cancer that was performed by the Gynecologic Oncology Group to determine the ORR, PFS, and toxicity for this treatment. Patients must have been administered 1-2 prior cytotoxic regimens. Treatment consisted of bevacizumab (15 mg/kg) IV every 3 weeks until disease progression or prohibitive toxicity. Between April 2002 and August 2004, 64 patients were enrolled, of which 2 were excluded for wrong primary and borderline histology and 62 were evaluable (1 previous regimen=23, 2 previous regimens=39). The median disease free interval from completion of primary cytotoxic chemotherapy to first recurrence was 6.5 months. Early results demonstrated that some patients had confirmed objective responses and PFS in some was at least 6 months. Observed Grade 3 or 4 toxicities included allergy (Grade 3=1), cardiovascular (Grade 3=4; Grade 4=1), gastrointestinal (Grade 3=3), hepatic (Grade 3=1), pain (Grade 3=2), and pulmonary (Grade 4=1). As of 11/04, 36 patients were removed from the trial, including 29 for disease progression and 1 for toxicity in 33 cases reported. Preliminary evidence exists for objective responses to bevacizumab (Burger R, et al, ASCO05, Abs. 5009).An open label, single arm, 2-stage, phase II clinical trial (protocol ID: AVF2949g, NCT00097019) of bevacizumab in patients with platinum resistant, advanced (Stage III or IV), ovarian cancer or primary peritoneal cancer for whom subsequent doxorubicin or topotecan therapy also has failed was initiated in November 2004 at multiple locations in the USA to determine the safety and efficacy for this treatment.A multicenter phase II clinical trial was initiated in April 2002 to determine the 6-month PFS of patients with persistent or recurrent ovarian epithelial or primary peritoneal cancer treated with bevacizumab (protocol ID: GOG-0170D, CDR0000068839, NCT00022659). IV bevacizumab is administered over 30-90 minutes on day 1. Treatment is repeated every 21 days in the absence of disease progression or unacceptable toxicity. Patients are followed every 3 months for 2 years, every 6 months for 3 years, and then annually thereafter. A total of 22-60 patients will be accrued within 12-30 months. Robert A. Burger, MD, of Chao Family Comprehensive Cancer Center is Trial Chair.This trial was closed in August 2004.
In a followup to this original posting A Report From the Institute of Medicine of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine entitled
was generated in a ViewPoint piece in JAMA which discussed their Congressional mandated report on the State of the Science in Ovarian Cancer Research, titled
Ovarian Cancers: Evolving Paradigms in Research and Care
highlights some of the research gaps felt by the committee in the current state of ovarian cancer research including:
consideration in research protocols of the multitude of histologic and morphologic subtypes of ovarian cancer, including the feeling of the committee that high grade serous OVCA originates from the distal end of the fallopian tube (espoused by Dr. Doubeau and Dr. Christopher Crum) versus originating from the ovarian surface epithelium
a call for expanded screening and prevention research with mutimodal screening including CA125 with secondary transvaginal screen
better patient education of the risk/benefit of genetic testing including BRCA1/2 as well as in consideration for PARP inhibitor therapy
treatments should be standardized and disseminated including more research in health outcomes and decision support for personalized therapy
This Perspective article can be found here: jvp160038
Some other posts relating to OVARIAN CANCER on this site include
John Carroll reports on a disappointing ruling by the FDA on AstraZeneca’s PARP inhibitor olaparib for maintenance therapy in women with cisplatin refractory ovarian cancer with BRCA mutation. Early clinical investigations had pointed to efficacy of PARP inhibitors in ovarian tumors carrying the BRCA mutation. The scientific rationale was quite clear:
Dana Farber’s Dr. Ralph Scully, Ph.D., in Exploiting DNA Repair Targets in Breast Cancer (http://www.dfhcc.harvard.edu/news/news/article/5402/), explains his research investigating why multiple DNA repair pathways may have to be targeted with PARP therapy concurrent with BRCA1 deficiency.
However FDA investigators voiced their skepticism of AstraZeneca’s clinical results, namely
Small number of patients enrolled
BRCA1/2 cohort were identified retrospectively
results skewed by false benefit from “underperforming” control arm
possible inadvertent selection bias
hazard ratio suggesting improvement in progression free survival but higher risk/benefit
The FDA investigators released their report two days before an expert panel would be releasing their own report (reported in the link below from FierceBiotech)
in which the expert panel reiterated the findings of the FDA investigators. The expert panel’s job was to find if there was any clinical benefit for continuing consideration of olaparib, basically stating
“This trial has problems,” noted FDA cancer chief Richard Pazdur during the panel discussion. If investigators had “pristine evidence of a 7-month advantage in PFS, we wouldn’t be here.”
The expert panel was concerned for the above reasons as well as the reported handful of lethal cases of myelodysplastic syndrome and acute myeloid leukemia in the study, although the panel noted these patients had advanced disease before entering the trial, raising the possibility that prior drugs may have triggered their deaths.
As John Carrol from FierceBiotech notes, the decision may spark renewed interest by Pfizer of a bid for AstraZeneca as the potential FDA rejection would certainly dampen AstraZeneca’s future growth and profit plans. Last month AstraZeneca’s CEO made the case to shareholders to reject the Pfizer offer by pointing to AstraZeneca’s potential beefed-up pipeline.
However, on the same day, FierceBiotechreports some great news (at least in Europe) on the ovarian cancer front:
EU Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) handed down a positive ruling on Avastin, recommending that the European Commission approve the drug for use in women with ovarian cancer that’s resistant to platinum-based chemotherapy. It’s the first biologic to receive a positive opinion from the CHMP for this hard-to-treat form of the disease.
EU had been getting pressure from British doctors to approve Avastin based on clinical trial results although it may be important to note that the EU zone seems to have an ability to recruit more numbers for clinical trials than in US. For instance a wonen’s breast cancer prevention trial had heavy recruitment in what would be considered a short time frame compared to the US.
Multi-drug, Multi-arm, Biomarker-driven Clinical Trial for patients with Squamous Cell Carcinoma called the Lung Cancer Master Protocol, or Lung-MAP launched by NCI, Foundation Medicine, and Five Pharma Firms
Reporter: Aviva Lev-Ari, PhD, RN
NEW YORK (GenomeWeb) — A group of pharmaceutical companies, research groups, foundations, and the clinical sequencing firm Foundation Medicine have joined to initiate a multi-drug, multi-arm, biomarker-driven clinical trial for patients with squamous cell carcinoma called the Lung Cancer Master Protocol, or Lung-MAP.
The public-private collaboration includes support from the National Cancer Institute, the Foundation of the National Institutes of Health, SWOG Cancer Research, and Friends of Cancer Research. It will also involve funding and participation from five pharmaceutical companies: Amgen, Genentech, Pfizer, AstraZeneca, and AstraZeneca’s global biologics R&D arm MedImmune, as well as Foundation Medicine.
The Bonnie J. Addario Lung Cancer Foundation also announced yesterday that it had signed on as a trial collaborator. Other lung cancer advocacy partners include the American Cancer Society, Free to Breathe, Lung Cancer Alliance, LUNGevity, and Uniting Against Lung Cancer.
The study will recruit patients with advanced squamous cell lung cancer — which represents about 25 percent of all lung cancer diagnoses — from over 200 medical centers through the NCI’s NCTN and SWOG, the groups said.
According to an announcement by the NCI, researchers in the trial will use Foundation Medicine’s technology to screen patients for alterations in 200 cancer-related genes. Based on their results, the group will randomize patients to one of five treatment arms from the pipelines of participating pharma partners or to a control arm matched to each drug.
The targeted treatment arms include four investigational genomically targeted drugs — Amgen’s c-MET inhibitor rilotumumab, an AstraZeneca FGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitor, AZD4547, Genentech/Roche’s Taselisib, and Pfizer’s Palbociclib — as well as one anti PD-L1 immunotherapy, MedImmune’s MEDI4736.
The group anticipates that the trial will screen between 500 and 1,000 patients per year.
The NCI’s Jeff Abrams said in a statement that the Lung-MAP represents “the first of several planned large, genomically driven treatment trials that will be conducted by NCI’s newly formed National Clinical Trials Network.”
Unlike traditional clinical trials, the Lung-MAP effort will allow the recruitment of patients with relatively rare genomic alterations to a variety of different targeted therapies at the same time, instead of testing and eliminating patients from individual trials of one targeted drug at a time.
Maria Friere, president and executive director of the FNIH, said that traditional clinical trials “have long imposed significant recruitment and infrastructure burdens on researchers and patients, with frustratingly slow results.” The new Lung-MAP trial “will validate biomarkers and facilitate drug development in one infrastructure to more rapidly provide safer and more effective treatments to patients.”
According to the NCI’s announcement, the trial could be expanded to test as many as five to seven additional drugs over the next five years at a cost of up to $160 million.
Can Mobile Health Apps Improve Oral-Chemotherapy Adherence? The Benefit of Gamification.
Reporter: Stephen J. Williams, PhD
Article ID #144: Can Mobile Health Apps Improve Oral-Chemotherapy Adherence? The Benefit of Gamification. Published on 6/17/2014
WordCloud Image Produced by Adam Tubman
A report on how gamification mobile applications, like CyberDoctor’s PatientPartner, may improve patient adherence to oral chemotherapy.
(includes interviews with CyberDoctor’s CEO Akhila Satish and various oncologists)
Writer/Curator: Stephen J. Williams, Ph.D.
UPDATE 5/15/2019
Please see below for an UPDATE on this post including results from the poll conducted here on the value of a gamification strategy for oral chemotherapy patient adherence as well as a paper describing a well designed development of an application specifically to address this clinical problem.
Studies have pointed to a growing need to monitor and improve medical adherence, especially with outpatient prescription drugs across many diseases, including cancer.
The trend to develop oral chemotherapies, so patients can take their medications in the convenience of their home, has introduced produced a unique problem concerning cancer patient-medication adherence. Traditionally, chemotherapies were administered by a parental (for example intravenous) route by clinic staff, however, as noted by Jennifer M Gangloff in her article Troubling Trend: Medication Adherence:
with the trend of cancer patients taking their oral medication at home, the burden of adherence has shifted from clinicians to the patients and their families.
A few highlights from Jennifer Gangloff’s article highlight the degree and scope of the problem:
There is a wide range of adherence for oral chemo– as low as 16% up to 100% adherence rates have been seen in multiple studies
High cost in lives and money: estimates in US of 125,000 deaths and $300 billion in healthcare costs due to nonadherence to oral anticancer medications
Factors not related to the patient can contribute to nonadherence including lack of information provided by the healthcare system and socioeconomic factors
Numerous methods to improve adherence issues (hospital informative seminars, talking pill bottles, reminder phone calls etc.) have met with mixed results.
More strikingly, patient adherence rates can drastically decline over treatment, with one study showing an adherence rate drop from 87% to 50% over 4 years of adjuvant tamoxifen therapy.
Tackling The Oral Chemotherapy-Patient Adherence Problem
Documented factors leading to non-adherence to oral oncology medications include
Patient feels better so stop taking the drug
Patient feels worse so stops taking the drug
Confusing and complicated dosing regimen
Inability to afford medications
Poor provider-patient relationships
Adverse effects of medication
Cognitive impairment (“chemo fog”; mental impairment due to chemotherapy
Inadequate education/instruction of discharge
There are many examples of each reason why a patient stopped taking medication. One patient was prescribed capecitabine for her metastatic breast cancer and, upon feeling nausea, started to use antacids, which precipitated toxicities as a result of increased plasma levels of capecitabine.
This review also documented the difficulties in accurately measuring patient adherence including:
Inaccuracy of self-reporting
Lack of applicability of external measurements such as pill counts
Hawthorne effect: i.e. patient pill documentation reminds them to take next dose
The group suggests that using MTM programs, especially telephony systems involving oncology nurses and pharmacists and utilizing:
Therapy support (dosing reminders)
Education
Side effect management
may be a cost-efficient methodology to improve medical adherence.
Although nurses are important intermediary educating patients about their oral chemotherapies, it does not appear that solely relying on nurses to monitor patient adherence will be sufficient, as indicated in a survey-based Japanese study.
Survey results indicated that 90% of nurses reported asking patients on oral chemotherapy about emergency contacts, side effects, and family/friend support. Nurses also provided patients with education materials on their assigned medication.
However, less than one-third of nurses asked if their patients felt confident about managing their oral chemotherapy.
“Nurses were less likely to ask adherence-related questions of patients with refilled prescriptions than of new patients,” the researchers wrote. “Regarding unused doses of anticancer agents, 35.5% of nurses reported that they did not confirm the number of unused doses when patients had refilled prescriptions.”
From the Roswell Park Cancer Institute blog post Making Mobile Health Work
US physicians are recognizing the need for the adoption of mobile in their practice but choice of apps and mobile strategies must be carefully examined before implementation. In addition, most physicians are using mobile communications as a free-complementary service and these physicians are not being reimbursed for their time.
Some companies are providing their own oncology-related mobile app services:
San Francisco, August 13, 2013 – CollabRx, Inc. (NASDAQ: CLRX), a healthcare information technology company focused on informing clinical decision making in molecular medicine, today announced a multi-year agreement with Everyday Health’s MedPage Today. The forthcoming app, which will target oncologists and pathologists, will focus on the molecular aspects of laboratory testing and therapy development. Over time, the expectation is that this app will serve as a comprehensive point of care resource for physicians and patients to obtain highly credible, expert-vetted and dynamically updated information to guide cancer treatment planning.
The McKesson Foundation’s Mobilizing for Health initiative
has awarded a grant to Partners HealthCare’s Center for Connected Health to develop a mobile health program that uses a smartphone application to help patients with cancer adhere to oral chemotherapy treatments and monitor their symptoms, FierceMobileHealthcare reports.
CancerNet announces mobile application (from cancer.net)
The report suggests that there are too many apps either offering information, suggesting behavior/lifestyle changes, or measuring compliance data but little evidence to suggest any of these are working the way they intended. The article suggests the plethora of apps may just be adding to the confusion.
MyCyberDoctor™, a True Gamification App, Shows Great Results in Improving Diabetics Medical Adherence and Health Outcome
Most of the mobile health apps discussed above, would be classified as tracking apps, because the applications simply record a patient’s actions, whether filling a prescription, interacting with a doctor, nurse, pharmacist, or going to a website to gain information. However, as discussed before, there is no hard evidence this is really impacting health outcomes.
Another type of application, termed gamification apps, rely on role-playing by the patient to affect patient learning and ultimately behavior.
An interested twist on this method was designed by Akhila Satish, CEO and developer of CyberDoctor and a complementary application PatientPartner.
As reported here, the PatientPartner application was used in the first IRB-approved mhealth clinical-trial to see if the gamification app could improve medical adherence and outcomes in diabetic patients. PatientPartner is a story-driven game in changing health behavior and biomarkers (blood glucose levels in this trial). In the clinical trial, 100 non-adherent patients with diabetes played the PatientPartner game for 15 minutes. Results were amazing, as the trial demonstrated an increase in patient adherence, with only 15 minutes of game playing.
Results from the study
Patients with diabetes who used PatientPartner showed significant improvement in three key areas – medication, diet, and exercise:
Medication adherence increased by 37%, from 58% to 95% – equivalent to three additional days of medication adherence per week.
Diet adherence increased by 24% – equivalent to two days of additional adherence a week.
Exercise adherence increased by 14% – equivalent to one additional day of adherence per week.
HbA1c (a blood sugar measure) decreased from 10.7% to 9.7%.
As mentioned in the article:
The unique, universal, non-disease specific approach allows PatientPartner to be effective in improving adherence in all patient populations.
PatientPartner is available in the iTunes store and works on the iPhone and iPod Touch. For information on PatientPartner, visit www.mypatientpartner.com.
Ms. Satish, who was named one of the top female CEO’s at the Health Conference, gratuitously offered to answer a few questions for Leaders in Pharmaceutical Business Intelligence (LPBI) on the feasibility of using such a game (role-playing) application to improve medical adherence in the oncology field.
LPBI: The results you had obtained with patient-compliance in the area of diabetes are compelling and the clinical trial well-designed. In the oncology field, due to the increase in use of oral chemotherapeutics, patient-compliance has become a huge issue. Other than diabetes, are there plans for MyCyberDoctor and PatientPartner to be used in other therapeutic areas to assist with patient-compliance and patient-physician relations?
Ms. Satish: Absolutely! We tested the application in diabetes because we wanted to measure adherence from an objective blood marker (hbA1c). However, the method behind PatientPartner- teaching patients how to make healthy choices- is universal and applicable across therapeutic areas.
LPBI: Recently, there have been a plethora of apps developed which claim to impact patient-compliance and provide information. Some of these apps have been niche (for example only providing prescription information but tied to pharmacy records and company databases). Your app seems to be the only one with robust clinical data behind it and approaches from a different angle, namely adjusting behavior using a gamefying experience and teaching the patient the importance of compliance. How do you feel this approach geared more toward patient education sets PatientPartner apart from other compliance-based apps?
Ms. Satish: PatientPartner really focuses on the how of patient decision making, rather than the specifics of each decision that is made. It’s a unique approach, and part of the reason PatientPartner works so effectively with such a short initial intervention! We are able to achieve more with less “app” time as a result of this method.
LPBI: There have been multiple studies attempting to correlate patient adherence, decision-making, and health outcome to socioeconomic status. In some circumstances there is a socioeconomic correlation while other cases such as patient-decision to undergo genetic testing or compliance to breast cancer treatment in rural areas, level of patient education may play a bigger role. Do you have data from your diabetes trial which would suggest any differences in patient adherence, outcome to any socioeconomic status? Do you feel use of PatientPartner would break any socioeconomic barriers to full patient adherence?
Ms. Satish: Within our trial, we had several different clinical sites. This helped us test the product out in a broad, socioeconomically diverse population. It is our hope that with a tool as easy to scale and use as PatientPartner we have the opportunity to see the product used widely, even in populations that are traditionally harder to reach.
LPBI: There has been a big push for the development of individual, personalized physician networks which use the internet as the primary point of contact between a primary physician and the patient. Individuals may sign up to these networks bypassing the traditional insurance-based networks. How would your application assist in these types of personalized networks?
Ms. Satish: PatientPartner can easily be plugged into any existing framework of communication between patient and provider. We facilitate patient awareness, engagement and accountability- all of which are important regardless of the network structure.
LBPI: Thank you Akhila!
A debate has begun about regulating mobile health applications, and although will be another post, I would just like to summarize a nice article in May, 2014 Oncology Times by Sarah Digiulo “Mobile Health Apps: Should They be Regulated?
In general, in the US there are HIPAA regulations about the dissemination of health related information between a patient and physician. Most of the concerns are related to personal health information made public in an open-access platform such as Twitter or Facebook.
In addition, according to Dr. Don Dizon M.D., Director of the Oncology Sexual Health Clinic at Massachusetts General Hospital, it may be more difficult to design applications directed against a vast, complex disease like cancer with its multiple subtypes than for diabetes.
Mobile Health Applications on Rise in Developing World: Worldwide Opportunity
According to International Telecommunication Union (ITU) statistics, world-wide mobile phone use has expanded tremendously in the past 5 years, reaching almost 6 billion subscriptions. By the end of this year it is estimated that over 95% of the world’s population will have access to mobile phones/devices, including smartphones.
This presents a tremendous and cost-effective opportunity in developing countries, and especially rural areas, for physicians to reach patients using mHealth platforms.
Drs. Clara Aranda-Jan Neo Mohutsiwa and Svetla Loukanova had conducted a systematic review of the literature on mHealth projects conducted in Africa[1] to assess the reliability of mobile phone and applications to assist in patient-physician relationships and health outcomes. The authors reviewed forty four studies on mHealth projects in Africa, determining their:
strengths
weaknesses
opportunities
threats
to patient outcomes using these mHealth projects. In general, the authors found that mHealth projects were beneficial for health-related outcomes and their success related to
accessibility
acceptance and low-cost
adaptation to local culture
government involvement
while threats to such projects could include
lack of funding
unreliable infrastructure
unclear healthcare system responsibilities
Dr.Sreedhar Tirunagari, an oncologist in India, agrees that mHealth, especially gamification applications could greatly foster better patient education and adherencealthough he notes that mHealth applications are not really used in India and may not be of much use for those oncology patients living in rural areas, as cell phone use is not as prevalent as in the bigger inner cities such as Delhi and Calcutta.
1) do you see a use for such apps which either track drug compliance or use gamification systems to teach patients the importance of continuing their full schedule of drug therapy
2) do you feel patient- drug compliance issues in the oncology practice is due to lack of information available to the patient or issues related to drug side effects?
“I think that Apps could help in this setting, we are in
Informatics era but..
The main question is that chronic patients are special ones.
Cancer patients have to deal with prognosis, even in therapies
with curative intent such as aromatase inhibitors are potent
Drugs that can cure; only in the future the patients know.
But meanwhile he or she has to deal with side-effects every day. A PC can help but suffer this symptoms…it. Is a real problem believe me!”
“The main app is his/her doctor”
I would like to invite all oncologists to answer the poll question ABOVE about the use of such gamification apps, like PatientPartner, for improving medical adherence to oral chemotherapy.
UPDATE 5/15/2019
The results of the above poll, although limited, revealed some interesting insights. Although only five oncologists answered the poll whether they felt gamification applications could help with oral chemotherapy patient adherence, all agreed it would be worthwhile to develop apps based on gamification to assist in the outpatient setting. In addition, one oncologist felt that the success of mobile patient adherence application would depend on the type of cancer. None of the oncologist who answered the survey thought that gamification apps would have no positive effect on patient adherence to their chemotherapy. With this in light, a recent paper by Joel Fishbein of University of Colorado and Joseph Greer from Massachusetts General Hospital, describes the development of a mobile application, in clinical trial, to promote patient adherence to their oral chemotherapy.
Mobile Applications to Promote Adherence to Oral Chemotherapy and Symptom Management: A Protocol for Design and Development
Oral chemotherapy is increasingly used in place of traditional intravenous chemotherapy to treat patients with cancer. While oral chemotherapy includes benefits such as ease of administration, convenience, and minimization of invasive infusions, patients receive less oversight, support, and symptom monitoring from clinicians. Additionally, adherence is a well-documented challenge for patients with cancer prescribed oral chemotherapy regimens. With the ever-growing presence of smartphones and potential for efficacious behavioral intervention technology, we created a mobile health intervention for medication and symptom management.
OBJECTIVE:
The objective of this study was to develop and evaluate the usability and acceptability of a smartphone app to support adherence to oral chemotherapy and symptom management in patients with cancer.
METHODS:
We used a 5-step development model to create a comprehensive mobile app with theoretically informed content. The research and technical development team worked together to develop and iteratively test the app. In addition to the research team, key stakeholders including patients and family members, oncology clinicians, health care representatives, and practice administrators contributed to the content refinement of the intervention. Patient and family members also participated in alpha and beta testing of the final prototype to assess usability and acceptability before we began the randomized controlled trial.
RESULTS:
We incorporated app components based on the stakeholder feedback we received in focus groups and alpha and beta testing. App components included medication reminders, self-reporting of medication adherence and symptoms, an education library including nutritional information, Fitbit integration, social networking resources, and individually tailored symptom management feedback. We are conducting a randomized controlled trial to determine the effectiveness of the app in improving adherence to oral chemotherapy, quality of life, and burden of symptoms and side effects. At every stage in this trial, we are engaging stakeholders to solicit feedback on our progress and next steps.
CONCLUSIONS:
To our knowledge, we are the first to describe the development of an app designed for people taking oral chemotherapy. The app addresses many concerns with oral chemotherapy, such as medication adherence and symptom management. Soliciting feedback from stakeholders with broad perspectives and expertise ensured that the app was acceptable and potentially beneficial for patients, caregivers, and clinicians. In our development process, we instantiated 7 of the 8 best practices proposed in a recent review of mobile health app development. Our process demonstrated the importance of effective communication between research groups and technical teams, as well as meticulous planning of technical specifications before development begins. Future efforts should consider incorporating other proven strategies in software, such as gamification, to bolster the impact of mobile health apps. Forthcoming results from our randomized controlled trial will provide key data on the effectiveness of this app in improving medication adherence and symptom management.
In this paper, Fishbein et al. describe the methodology of the developoment of a mobile application to promote oral chemotherapy adherence. This mobile app intervention was named CORA or ChemOtheRapy Assistant.
Of the approximately 325,000 health related apps on the market (as of 2017), the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) have only reviewed approximately 20 per year and as of 2016 cleared only about 36 health related apps.
According to industry estimates, 500 million smartphone users worldwide will be using a health care application by 2015, and by 2018, 50 percent of the more than 3.4 billion smartphone and tablet users will have downloaded mobile health applications. However, there is not much scientific literature providing a framework for design and creation of quality health related mobile applications.
Methods
The investigators separated the app development into two phases: Phase 1 consisted of the mobile application development process and initial results of alpha and beta testing to determine acceptability among the major stakeholders including patients, caregivers, oncologists, nurses, pharmacists, pharmacologists, health payers, and patient advocates. Phase 1 methodology and results were the main focus of this paper. Phase 2 consists of an ongoing clinical trial to determine efficacy and reliability of the application in a larger number of patients at different treatment sites and among differing tumor types.
The 5 step development process in phase 1 consisted of identifying features, content, and functionality of a mobile app in an iterative process, including expert collaboration and theoretical framework to guide initial development.
There were two distinct teams: a research team and a technical team. The multidisciplinary research team consisted of the principal investigator, co-investigators (experts in oncology, psychology and psychiatry), a project director, and 3 research assistants.
The technical team consisted of programmers and project managers at Partners HealthCare Connected Health. Stakeholders served as expert consultants including oncologists, health care representatives, practice administrators, patients, and family members (care givers). All were given questionaires (HIPAA compliant) and all involved in alpha and beta testing of the product.
There were 5 steps in the development process
Implementing a theoretical framework: Patients and their family caregivers now bear the primary responsibility for their medical adherence especially to oral chemotherapy which is now more frequently administered in the home setting not in the clinical setting. Four factors were identified as the most important barriers to oral chemotherapy adherence: complexity of medication regimes, symptom burden, poor self-management of side effects, and low clinical support. These four factors were integral in the design of the mobile app and made up a conceptual framework in its design.
Conducting Initial Focus Group Interviews with key stakeholders: Stakeholders were taken from within and outside the local community. In all 32 stakeholders served as study collaborators including 8 patient/families, 8 oncologists/clinicians, 8 cancer practice administrators, and 8 representatives of the health system, community, and overall society. The goal of these focus groups were to obtain feedback on the proposed study and design included perceived importance of monitoring of adherence to oral chemotherapy, barriers to communication between patients and oncology teams regarding side effects and medication adherence, potential role of mobile apps to address barriers of quality of cancer care, potential feasibility, acceptability, and usage and feedback on the overall study design.
Creation of Wireframes (like storyboards or page designs) and Collecting Initial Feedback: The research and design team, in conjunction with stakeholder input, created content wireframes, or screen blueprints) to provide a visual guide as to what the app would look like. These wireframes also served as basis for what the patient interviews would look like on the application. A total of 10 MGH (Massachusetts General Hospital) patients (6 female, 4 male) and most with higher education (BS or higher) participated in the interviews and design of wireframes. Eight MGH clinicians participated in this phase of wireframe design.
Developing, Programming, and Refining the App: CORA was designed to be supported by PHP/MySQL databases and run on LAMP hosts (Linux, Apache, MySQL, Perl/PHP/Python) and fully HIPAA compliant. Alpha testing was conducted with various stakeholders and the app refined by the development team (technical team) after feedback.
Final beta testing and App prototype for clinical trial: The research team considered the first 5 participants enrolled in the subsequent clinical trial for finalization of the app prototype.
There were 7 updated versions of the app during the initial clinical trial phase and 4 updates addressed technical issues related to smartphone operating system upgrades.
Finally, the investigators list a few limitations in their design and study of this application. First the patient population was homogenous as all were from an academic hospital setting. Second most of the patients were of Caucasian ethnic background and most were highly educated, all of which may introduce study bias. In addition, CORA was available on smartphone and tablet only, so a larger patient population who either have no access to these devices or are not technically savvy may experience issues related to this limitation.
In addition other articles on this site related to Mobile Health applications and Health Outcomes include
Aranda-Jan CB, Mohutsiwa-Dibe N, Loukanova S: Systematic review on what works, what does not work and why of implementation of mobile health (mHealth) projects in Africa. BMC public health 2014, 14:188.
An FDA advisory committee unanimously recommended approval of the Lutonix drug-coated balloon PTA catheter for the treatment of patients with femoropopliteal occlusive disease.
Circulatory System Devices Advisory Panel Provides a Unanimous Favorable Recommendation to FDA for the Lutonix® Drug Coated Balloon
Lutonix® DCB one step closer to becoming the first FDA-approved drug coated balloon for the treatment of patients with femoropopliteal occlusive disease
MURRAY HILL, N.J.–(BUSINESS WIRE)–Jun. 12, 2014– C. R. Bard, Inc. (NYSE:BCR) today announced that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) Circulatory System Devices Advisory Panel provided a unanimous favorable recommendation to FDA for use of the Lutonix® Drug Coated Balloon PTA Catheter (DCB) in the U.S. The Lutonix® DCB is currently under review by FDA for improving luminal diameter and reducing the incidence of restenosis for the treatment of obstructive de novo or non-stented restenotic lesions (≤ 15 cm in length) in native femoropopliteal arteries with reference vessel diameters of 4 mm to 6 mm. If approved, it is expected that the Lutonix® DCB will be the first and only FDA-approved DCB available in the U.S.
Data presented at today’s advisory committee meeting included one-year primary endpoint data from the LEVANT 2 pivotal study, which is a global, prospective, single-blind, randomized, 54-site study (42 sites in the U.S. and 12 in Europe) that enrolled all patients under one protocol. LEVANT 2 investigators have submitted a manuscript for publication with a top-tier medical journal.
At one year, LEVANT 2 demonstrated superior primary patency of the target lesion with the Lutonix®DCB for the efficacy endpoint (73.5% vs. 56.8%, p<0.001 by Kaplan-Meier time-to-event analysis) and non-inferiority for the safety endpoint; both endpoints were compared to standard percutaneous transluminal balloon angioplasty (PTA).
The secondary efficacy endpoint results at one year for patients randomized to treatment with the Lutonix® DCB demonstrated superiority in binary restenosis (26.5% vs. 43.2%, p<0.001 by Kaplan-Meier time-to-event analysis at 365 days) when compared to uncoated balloons, and measurable but not statistically significant improvement in freedom from target lesion revascularization (TLR) (89.7% vs. 84.8%, p=0.1673 by Kaplan-Meier time-to-event analysis).
Comparing results to other trials can be challenging and misleading, as each study may have varying patient profiles, protocol structures and other criteria that may affect the reported outcomes. LEVANT 2 raises the bar for scientific rigor in superficial femoral artery (SFA) trials and was designed to reduce bias in the results in order to accurately and scientifically assess and compare the long-term performance of key clinical measures. Two key aspects of the study design differentiate this trial from recent SFA studies. First, unlike some other SFA trials, the LEVANT 2 clinical trial did not count bail-out stenting as a primary patency or TLR failure. Second, to reduce the potential introduction of bias into the subjective clinical decision for revascularization, the protocol required the clinical assessment to be performed by a physician who was blinded to the treatment group and the doppler patency measurement.
This methodology of blinding the evaluating physicians in SFA trials is unique to LEVANT 2. Published data suggest that trials with less rigorous blinding methodologies have shown physicians to intervene more often in the control arm than in the treatment arm, even when presented with similar objective results such as binary restenosis. This can have a significant impact on subjective results, such as TLR. For example, the blinding methodology in LEVANT 2 showed very similar rates of intervention when binary restenosis occurred in either arm of the trial. If instead the evaluating physicians in LEVANT 2 had intervened at the rates in unblinded DCB trials when binary restenosis occurred (as estimated from public data), the company estimates the comparable freedom from TLR for LEVANT 2 could have been approximately 94% in the treatment arm compared to approximately 78% in the control arm at one year.
PTA balloons are a well-established and accepted treatment for peripheral arterial disease (PAD) according to the American College of Cardiology and American Heart Association guidelines. The Lutonix® DCB is a standard angioplasty balloon that is coated with a low dose of the anti-restenotic agent, paclitaxel, and is designed as adjunct therapy to standard mechanical dilatation of the vessel to restore blood flow. Successful treatment of PAD in the femoropopliteal arteries requires improved blood flow (patency) for longer periods of time. PTA is typically the first and preferred method to treat patients with PAD.
“The PAD patient population is growing and the variety of treatment needs for these challenging patients is increasing,” said Kenneth Rosenfield, M.D., Section Head for Vascular Medicine and Intervention, Massachusetts General Hospital and LEVANT 2 Co-Primary Investigator. “There is a need to improve upon the current well-established treatment modality and the Lutonix® DCB can be another tool to treat PAD in the difficult anatomy of the femoropopliteal artery without leaving an implant behind.”
The FDA will consider the positive recommendation of the advisory panel in its review of the PreMarket Approval (PMA) Application that was submitted by C. R. Bard in November 2013. Currently, the Lutonix® DCB is available commercially in Europe.
Timothy M. Ring, chairman and chief executive officer of C. R. Bard, commented, “We are hopeful that the unanimous positive recommendation for Lutonix® DCB is the next step in establishing a new standard of care for those patients in the U.S. confronted with femoropopliteal occlusive disease. Clinicians have been calling for a first-line alternative treatment to expand the therapy options for this painful, progressive and debilitating disease and we look forward to working closely with the FDA as it completes its review.”
About Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAD) and Treatment Options
PAD is a life-threatening condition that narrows arteries and reduces blood flow to limbs1 putting millions of people in danger of heart attack, stroke and potential lower-extremity amputation.2 The American Heart Association (AHA) estimates that PAD affects at least 8 million Americans with approximately 3 percent of people younger than 60 years and 20 percent of people older than 70 years affected by lower-extremity peripheral arterial disease.
There are both noninvasive and invasive SFA treatment options available, each of which has associated limitations. The most conservative approach is treatment with pharmacotherapy and/or exercise with risk factor modification; however, the effectiveness of these treatment options is often limited by patient intolerance to medication or lack of medication efficacy. Surgical bypass is at the other end of the spectrum. For most patients who fail conservative therapy alone, interventionalists and surgeons will typically offer percutaneous endovascular procedure as the initial treatment option, as a lower risk alternative to surgical bypass. PTA is the first-line, standard-of-care treatment for PAD, according to the American College of Cardiology and American Heart Association 2011 guideline; however, it is limited by its relative lack of long-term patency.
C. R. Bard, Inc. (www.crbard.com), headquartered in Murray Hill, NJ, is a leading multinational developer, manufacturer and marketer of innovative, life-enhancing medical technologies in the fields of vascular, urology, oncology and surgical specialty products.
The FDA advisory panel vote should not be construed as an indication of the likelihood of the product gaining regulatory approval or being successful commercially. This press release may contain forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, which are based on management’s current expectations, the accuracy of which is necessarily subject to risks and uncertainties. These statements are not historical in nature and use words such as “anticipate”, “estimate”, “expect”, “project”, “intend”, “forecast”, “plan”, “believe”, and other words of similar meaning in connection with any discussion of future operating or financial performance. Many factors may cause actual results to differ materially from anticipated results including product developments, sales efforts, income tax matters, the outcomes of contingencies such as legal proceedings, and other economic, business, competitive and regulatory factors. The company undertakes no obligation to update its forward-looking statements. Please refer to the Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Information in our March 31, 2014 Form 10-Q for more detailed information about these and other factors that may cause actual results to differ materially from those expressed or implied.
Source: C. R. Bard, Inc.
C. R. Bard, Inc. Investor Relations: Todd W. Garner, 908-277-8065 Vice President, Investor Relations or Media Relations: Scott T. Lowry, 908-277-8365 Vice President and Treasurer
FDA reveals details from Apple’s 2013 meeting with the agency, during which the tech giant discussed medical applications and FDA regulation of sensor-enabled mobile devices.
FDA regulators finally opened up about last year’s chat with consumer technology giant Apple (NSDQ:AAPL), opening the books on a meeting that spurred a lot of speculation about the company’s healthcare prospects.
According to meeting minutes obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request filed by 9to5Mac.com, Apple spoke with the FDA about its “moral obligation to do more” with its technology, especially given the capability of its smartphones to support sensors that may have implications for how users track and view their health.
“For instance, Apple’s devices have cameras and accelerometers,” according to the meeting memorandum provided by the FDA. “There is still an opportunity to innovate, but Apple wants to make sure they are on the side of the FDA.”
The meeting also lingered on regulatory oversight of mobile healthcare products, with Apple apparently lauding the FDA for its “fair” and “balanced” approach and FDA appearing to assuage the company’s concerns about oversight of the technology used in new healthcare applications.
Even a glucometer would not need FDA oversight, the agency told Apple, unless the device was explicitly marketed for medical use. The agency may get involved after the fact, however, if it sees the device making its way into medical use regardless of how it’s marketed.
“FDA will regulated [sic] based on the intended use of a device. Using the glucometer example, the glucometer may be unregulated if the intent is for a user to follow their blood sugar for the purposes of better nutrition,” according to the meeting memo. “If the glucometer is marketed for diabetics, however, it would more likely be regulated as a medical device. FDA looks at how devices are actually used. If the manufacturer advertises the device for an unapproved use of FDA sees a lot of off-label use that is potentially dangerous, FDA may regulate after the fact.”
The December 2013 meeting generated a lot of buzz from tech industry analysts who spotted Apple’s emerging interest in the healthcare space, which has also drawn rival consumer electronics companies such as LG Electronics (KRX:066570) and Samsung (LON:BC94).
Apple has been nabbing up experts from companies in the health, fitness and sensor space, and even took a couple along to the FDA meeting, including former Masimo (NSDQ:MASI) chief medical officer Michael O’Reilly. Apple also recently hired a couple of other medical sensor experts, including Nancy Dougherty, formerly involved with transdermal drug delivery devices and wearable vital signs monitoring, and Ravi Narasimhan, who also worked with personal vital signs monitoring.
The company early this year also landed a patent for a smartphone heart sensor, although that application laid out plans to use the sensor primarily for personalization and authentication.
Months of speculation came to a head last week when Apple finally unveiled its rumored “HealthKit” project and “Health” app, which aims to become a mobile silo for personal health and fitness information, including patient-generated data and information generated through various physician portals.
The secretive company has not yet commented on ongoing rumors that its interest in sensor technology will include a new “iWatch” wearable device, which would further feed data into the Health app. Analysts with RBC Capital said in a note to investors this month that Apple may announce a wearable product in October or November this year, and that such a technology represents a “material opportunity” for the company.
Rival phone-maker Samsung has also been making major moves in digital health with the launch of its wearables platform, including the ‘Simband’ hardware and ‘SAMI’ software, made open to developers. Samsung president and chief strategy officer has called digital health the “single greatest opportunity of our generation,” adding that the company is on the lookout for new ways to meld technology and health.
The following discussion will be a review of the current interest in Avemar, a nontoxic, fermentation product of wheat germ extract, garnering interest with respect to alternative and complementary medicinal use.
Extracts from an interview by Sandra Cascio with Mate Hidvegi
Mate’s Transylvania Professor Lajos David was the organizer of the Department of Pharmacy of the University of Szeged in the 1920’s. He was elected as the Dean of the Faculty of Medicine, the first and only pharmacist who reached this high position at the University since. Dr. Hidvegy’s grandfather was a devout Roman catholic, who publicly opposed Nazi persecution of Jews during the Holocaust. One of his colleagues and, perhaps his best friend, was Albert SzentGyorgyi, the Nobel laureate who discovered vitaminC. SzentGyorgyi moved to the United States after World War II, where he turned to studies of muscle biochemistry. In his later years he turned to cancer research. He theorized that a revolutionary anticancer drug could be based upon vitamin C combined with methoxysubstituted benzoquinones, the precursors of which can be found in wheat germ. After completion of the PhD, Dr. Hidvegi spent two years with the Wheat Grain Trust in Winnipeg, Canada, before returning to Hungary in 1990. He decided to followthepathwaythat SzentGyorgyi was now engaged intocompletehisgoals.He contacted anoldfriend,GaborFodor, a brilliantchemist, also a collaborator withSzentGyorgyiincancerresearch.
He wasinvited by Hermann Esterbauer, the head of the Institute of Biochemistry at the University of Graz, to work in his laboratory. Thanks to the generosity of Professor Esterbauer, he accomplished much at Graz together with his student, Dr. Rita Farkas. It was soon after Szent-Gyorgyi’s death when, with the help of Dr. Fodor, they prepared the chemicals to make the drug Szent-Gyorgyi had intended to make, with encouragement from the great quantum biochemist, Janos Ladik. They made wheat germ extracts with the highest free benzoquinone content.This required a fermentation process to liberate the benzoquinone moieties from the chemical bonds which keep them in natural forms: in glycosides. He recalls the purple colored active molecules in the fermentation liquid. Living cells with their exo and endoenzymes are used to split bonds and make new molecules. This is also true for the manufacturing process of Avemar. This extract contains new molecules which cannot be found elsewhere.
“WhenAvemar was voted by the majority of the more than 50,000 professionals for NutrAward, it became obvious that this product is of biological efficacy plus safety, and it is based on good science.” It received the financial support needed. From this, he was able to complete the experiments and get the approval for the registration. The time arrived when he really had to give a name to the product which had only had a code name. One late night it just came: Avemar, from the Latin prayer: Ave Maria.
Avemar with widely used chemotherapeutic drugs completely inhibited the development of metastases. Exploring its whole activity profile might even take a lifetime of research. So far he has supervised Avemar research done in Hungary, Israel, the United States, Austria, Italy, Spain, Slovakia, the Czech Republic, Germany,the United Kingdom, Russia, Australia, Korea, Vietnam. It has been a good experience to see the scientific interest it has generated worldwide. In 2009, Dr. Hidvegy received an invitation from the Nobel laureate, James Watson, codiscoverer of DNA’s double helix. It was a great honor. Avemar, he hopes,will be a significant cancer drug.
Mate Hidvegi was born in Budapest, Hungary, in 1955. He studied, thentaught at what is now Budapest Universityof Technology and Economics.After finishing university, he worked in the cereal industry and was codeveloper of patented feed advisory system basedon near infrared ingredientdata. In Hungary, Hidvegi was one of the pioneers in the development oftechnologies for large scale production of instantized extracts for therapeuticuse.
Carcinogenesis vol.22 no.10 pp.1649–1652, 2001
Wheat germ extract inhibits experimental colon carcino-genesis in F-344 rats
Attila Zalatnai, Karoly Lapis, Bela Szende, Erzsebet Raso, Andros Telekes, Akos Resetar, and Mate Hidvegi
It has been demonstrated for the first time that a wheat germ extract prevents colonic cancer in laboratory animals. Four-week-old inbred male F-344 rats were used in the study. Colon carcinogenesis was induced by azoxy-methane (AOM). Ten rats served as untreated controls (group 1). For the treatment of the animals in group 2, AOM was dissolved in physiologic saline and the animals were given three weekly subcutaneous injections at 15 mg/kg body weight (b/w). In two additional groups Avemar (MSC), a fermented wheat germ extract standardized to 2,6-dimethoxy-p-benzoquinone was administered as a tentative chemo-preventive agent. MSC was dissolved in water and was given by gavage at a dose of 3 g/kg b/w once a day. In group 3, animals started to receive MSC 2 weeks prior to the first injection of AOM daily and continuously thereafter until they were killed 32 weeks later. In group 4 only the basal diet and MSC were administered. At the end of the experiment all the rats were exsanguinated under a light ether anesthesia and necropsied. Percentage of animals developing colon tumors and number of tumors per animals: group 1 – 0 and 0; group 2– 83.0 and 2.3; group 3 – 44.8 (P ≤ 0.001) and 1.3 (P ≤ 0.004); group 4 – 0 and 0. All the tumors were histologically neoplastic. The numbers of the aberrant crypt foci (ACF) per area (cm2) in group 2 were 4.85 while in group 3 the ACF numbers were 2.03 only (P ≤ 0.0001).
Table I. Macroscopic findings in the large intestines of F-344 rats treated with MSC or MSC + AOM
No. of animals w/tumorw
Average
# tumors
Average
diameter
N
1
Untreated
controls (10)
0/10
0/10
2.
AOM (47)
39/47
(83.0%)
2.3 + 0.21
(range 1–8)
2.35 +
0.25
3.
MSC +
AOM (29)
13/29
(44.8%)
1.3 + 0.17
(range 1–3)
2.21 +
0.12
4.
MSC (9)
0/9
0/9
Fig. 1. Experimental schedule. Colon carcinogenesis was induced by three consecutive s.c. doses of AOM 1 week apart in F-344 rats. Oral administration of MSC was started 2 weeks before the carcinogen treatments. All the animals were killed at the end of the experiment, e.g. on the 32nd week. (not shown)
Summing up, although the chemoprevention of colon cancers (and their pre-neoplastic lesions) has well and long been established and could be achieved by totally different compounds, the mechanisms have still remained to be clarified. This is also true for MSC.
The exact mechanism by which the fermented wheat germ concentration can prevent colon cancer is still partly unknown. MSC did inhibit the AOM-induced ACF and colon neoplasm formation, the multiplicity of the tumors, apparently acting in the initiation phase. Regarding this, we can hypothesize that MSC acts as an immunomodulator.
Wheat Germ Extract Decreases Glucose Uptake and RNARibose Formation but Increases Fatty Acid Synthesis in MIAPancreatic Adenocarcinoma Cell
LG Boros, K Lapis, B Szende, R Tömösközi-Farkas, Ádám Balogh, …., and M Hidvégi
UCLA School of Medicine, Harbor-UCLA Research and Education Institute, Torrance, Ca.; First Institute of Pathology and Experimental Cancer Research, Semmelweis Medical University, Budapest, Hungary; Central Food Research Institute, Budapest, Hungary; Department of Surgery, Albert Szent-Gyorgyi Medical and Pharmaceutical Center, School of General Medicine, University of Szeged, Szeged, Hungary; Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Institut d’Investigacions Biomediques August Pi i Sunyer, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain; andDepartment of Biochemistryand Food Technology, Technical University of Budapest and Biromedicina Company, Budapest, Hungary
Pancreas 2001; 23 (2), pp. 141–147
Summary: The fermented wheat germ extract with standardized composition has potent tumor inhibitory properties. The fermented wheat germ extract controls tumor propagation. The authors show that this extract induces profound metabolic changes in cultured MIA pancreatic adenocarcinoma cells when the [1,2- 13C2] glucose isotope is used as the single tracer with biologic gas chromatography–mass spectrometry.
MIA cells treated with 0.1, 1, and 10 mg/mL wheat germ extract showed a dose-dependent decrease in cell glucose consumption, consumption, uptake of isotope into ribosomal RNA (2.4%, 9.4%, and 8.0%), and release of 13CO2 . Conversely, direct glucose oxidation and ribose recycling in the pentose cycle showed a dose-dependent increase of 1.2%, 20.7%, and 93.4%. The newly synthesized fraction of cell palmitate and the 13C enrichment of acetyl units were also increased with all doses of wheat germ extract.
The fermented wheat germ extract controls tumor propagation primarily by regulating glucose carbon redistribution between cell proliferation–related and cell differentiation–related macromolecules. Wheat germ extract treatment is likely associated with the phosphor-ylation and transcriptional regulation of metabolic enzymes that are involved in glucose carbon redistribution between cell the direct oxidative degradation of glucose,proliferation–related structural and functional macromolecules(RNA, DNA) and the direct oxidative degradation and survival of pancreatic adenocarcinoma cells in culture.
Fig 1 glu consumption of MIA pancreatic carcinoma cells in response to WGE
Figure 1. Glucose consumption of MIA pancreatic adenocarcinoma cells in response to increasing doses of fermented wheat germ extract (Avemar) treatment after 72 hours of culture. Glucose consumption (measured in milligrams) was estimated by the difference in media glucose content between Avemar-treated and control cultures. MIA cell glucose consumption was significantly inhibited in the presence of either 1 mg/mL (*p < 0.05) or 10 mg/mL (**p < 0.01) Avemar (x + SD; n = 6).
Figure 3. Ribosomal RNA synthesis of MIA pancreatic adenocarcinoma cells in response to increasing doses of fermented wheat germ extract (Avemar) treatment after 72 hours of culture. Glucose carbon incorporation into ribose isolated from ribosomal RNA is expressed as molar enrichment. The dose-dependent decrease in of rRNA after Avemar treatment indicates that ribosomal RNA synthesis is the primary site significantly affected by all doses of Avemar treatment with a maximum decrease of 29% after 10 mg/mL treatment (x + SD; n = 9; *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01).
changes in metabolic activity indicate that Avemar treatment affects cell metabolism primarily by decreasing glucose uptake and nucleic acid ribose synthesis while increasing glucose oxidation through the oxidative reactions of the pentose cycle and fatty acid synthesis from glucose carbon. The effect of Avemar treatment on lactate production and TCA cycle anapleurotic flux compared with glucose oxidation is less prominent
Fermented wheat germ extract induces apoptosis and downregulation of major histocompatibility complex class I proteins in tumor T and B cell lines
R FAJKA-BOJA, M HIDVÉGI, Y SHOENFELD, G ION, D DEMYDENKO, R TÖMÖSKÖZI-FARKAS, et al.
INTL J ONCOLOGY 2002; 20: 563-570.
Lymphocyte Signal Transduction Laboratory, Institute of Genetics, and Cytokine Group, Institute of Biochemistry, Biological Research Center of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Szeged; Department of Biochemistry and Food Technology, Budapest University of Technology and Economics, Budapest, Hungary; Department of Medicine ‘B’, Center for Autoimmune Diseases, Sheba Medical Center, Tel-Hashomer, Israel; Central Food Research Institute; National Institute of Oncology; Biromedicina Co., Budapest, Hungary
Abstract. The fermented wheat germ extract (code name: on cyto-fluorimeter using a monoclonal antibody to the MSC, trade name: Avemar), with standardized benzoquinone non-polymorphic region of the human MHC class I. MSC content has been shown to inhibit tumor propagation and stimulated tyrosine phosphorylation of intracellular proteins metastases formation in vivo. The aim of this study was to understand the molecular and cellular mechanisms of the anti-tumor effect of MSC. Therefore, we have designed in vitro model experiments using T and B tumor lymphocytic cell lines. As a result of the MSC treatment, cell surface MHC class I proteins was downregulated by 70-85% compared to the non-stimulated control.
Prominent apoptosis of and the influx of extracellular Ca2+ resulted in elevation of the amount of the intracellular Ca2+ concentration. 20-40% was detected upon 24 h of MSC treatment of the cell lines. Apoptosis was measured with cytofluorimetry by staining the DNA with propidium iodide and detecting the ‘sub-G ’ cell population.
Tyrosine phosphorylation of intra-cellular proteins and elevation of the intracellular Ca2+ concentration were examined using immunoblotting with anti-phosphotyrosine antibody and cytofluorimetry by means of Ca2+ sensitive fluorescence dyes, Fluo-3AM and FuraRed-AM, respectively. MSC did not induce a similar degree of apoptosis in healthy peripheral blood mononuclear cells.
Inhibition of the cellular tyrosine phosphatase activity or Ca2+ influx resulted in the opposite effect – increasing or diminishing the Avemar induced apoptosis as well as the MHC class I downregulation. The level of the cell surface MHC class I molecules was analysed with indirect immunofluorescence. The benzoquinone component (2,6-dimethoxi-p-benzoquinone) in MSC induced similar apoptosis and downregulation of the MHC class I molecules in the tumor T and B cell lines to that of MSC. These results suggest that MSC acts on lymphoid tumor cells by reducing MHC class I expression and selectively promoting apoptosis of tumor cells on a tyrosine phosphorylation and Ca2+ influx dependent way. One of the components in MSC, 2,6-dimethoxi-p-benzoquinone was shown to be an important factor in MSC mediated cell response.
Abbreviations:MHC, major histocompatibility complex;NK, natural killer;DMBQ, 2,6-dimethoxi-p-benzoquinone; FCS, fetal calf serum;PBMC, peripheral bloodmononuclear cells; TCR, T cell receptor;BCR, B cell receptor; mAb, monoclonal antibody;PMSF,phenylmethyl-sulfonylfluoride;pNPP, para-nitrophenyl-phosphate; PHA,phytohemagglutinineKey words: fermented wheat germ extract, Avemar, MSC, 2+ benzoquinone, tyrosine phosphorylation, intracellular Ca , CD45, tyrosine phosphatase, MHC class I downregulation, apoptosis
Figure 4. Apoptosis of tumor T cell lines and healthy lymphocytes upon MSC treatment. Jurkat cells were treated with 1 mg/ml MSC or .3 µg/ml DMBQ and PBMC were treated with 1 mg/ml
MSC for 24 h (A) or Jurkat cells were treated for 12 h (thick line in panel B). Control cells were left unstimulated (black bars in panel A or thin line on panel B). Apoptotic cells were enumerated
with the DNA analysis of the ‘sub-G ’ population (A) or with staining the cells with FITC1 labeled Annexin V
(B). Representative experiments are shown. The difference between the % of apoptosis in the case of treated and non-treated Jurkat cells was significant (MSC, p<0.001, n=14; DMBQ, p<0.05, n=3,
using paired, two-tailed t-test). No difference was found for PBMC (n=2).
MSC treatment causes prominent apoptosis in lymphoid tumor cells but it does not induce apoptosis of healthy resting mononuclear cells. Moreover, although MSC blocks the proliferation of PBM cells stimulated with PHA, it does not induce apoptosis in PHA stimulated cells (data not shown).