The Inequality and Health Disparity seen with the COVID-19 Pandemic Is Similar to Past Pandemics
Curator: Stephen J. Williams, PhD
It has become very evident, at least in during this pandemic within the United States, that African Americans and poorer communities have been disproportionately affected by the SARS-CoV2 outbreak . However, there are many other diseases such as diabetes, heart disease, and cancer in which these specific health disparities are evident as well :
Diversity and Health Disparity Issues Need to be Addressed for GWAS and Precision Medicine Studies
Personalized Medicine, Omics, and Health Disparities in Cancer: Can Personalized Medicine Help Reduce the Disparity Problem?
Disease like cancer have been shown to have wide disparities based on socioeconomic status, with higher incidence rates seen in poorer and less educated sub-populations, not just here but underdeveloped countries as well (see Opinion Articles from the Lancet: COVID-19 and Cancer Care in China and Africa) and graphics below)
In an article in Science by Lizzie Wade, these disparities separated on socioeconomic status, have occurred in many other pandemics throughout history, and is not unique to the current COVID19 outbreak. The article, entitled “An Unequal Blow”, reveal how
in past pandemics, people on the margins suffered the most.
Source: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/368/6492/700.summary
Health Disparities during the Black Death Bubonic Plague Pandemic in the 14th Century (1347-1351)
During the mid 14th century, all of Europe was affected by a plague induced by the bacterium Yersinia pestis, and killed anywhere between 30 – 60% of the European population. According to reports by the time the Black Death had reached London by January 1349 there had already been horrendous reports coming out of Florence Italy where the deadly disease ravished the population there in the summer of 1348 (more than half of the city’s population died). And by mid 1349 the Black Death had killed more than half of Londoners. It appeared that no one was safe from the deadly pandemic, affecting the rich, the poor, the young, the old.
However, after careful and meticulous archaeological and historical analysis in England and other sites, revealed a distinct social and economic inequalities that predominated and most likely guided the pandemics course throughout Europe. According to Dr. Gwen Robbins Schug, a bio-archaeologist at Appalachian State University,
Bio-archaeology and other social sciences have repeatedly demonstrated that these kinds of crises play out along the preexisting fault lines of each society. The people at greatest risk were often those already marginalized- the poor and minorities who faced discrimination in ways that damaged their health or limited their access to medical care even in pandemic times.
At the start of the Black Death, Europe had already gone under a climactic change with erratic weather. As a result, a Great Famine struck Europe between 1315-17. Wages fell and more people fell into poverty while the wealthiest expanded their riches, leading to an increased gap in wealth and social disparity. In fact according to recordkeeping most of Englanders were living below the poverty line.
Author Lizzie Wade also interviewed Dr. Sharon, DeWitte, a biological anthropologist at University of South Carolina, who looks at skeletal remains of Black Death victims to get evidence on their health status, like evidence of malnutrition, osteoporosis, etc. And it appears that most of the victims may have had preexisting health conditions indicative of poorer status. And other evidence show that wealthy landowners had a lower mortality rate than poorer inner city dwellers.
1918 Spanish Flu
Socioeconomic and demographic studies have shown that both Native American Indians and African Americans on the lower end of the socioeconomic status were disproportionately affected by the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic. According to census records, the poorest had a 50% higher mortality rate than wealthy areas in the city of Oslo. In the US, minors and factory workers died at the highest rates. In the US African Americans had already had bouts with preexisting issues like tuberculosis and may have contributed to the higher mortality. In addition Jim Crow laws in the South, responsible for widespread discrimination, also impacted the ability of African Americans to seek proper medical care.
From the Atlantic
Source: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/05/americas-health-segregation-problem/483219/
America’s Health Segregation Problem
Has the country done enough to overcome its Jim Crow health care history?
MAY 18, 2016
Like other forms of segregation, health-care segregation was originally a function of explicitly racist black codes and Jim Crow laws. Many hospitals, clinics, and doctor’s offices were totally segregated by race, and many more maintained separate wings or staff that could never intermingle under threat of law. The deficit of trained black medical professionals (itself caused by a number of factors including education segregation) meant that no matter where black people received health-care services, they would find their care to be subpar compared to that of whites. While there were some deaths that were directly attributable to being denied emergency service, most of the damage was done in establishing the same cumulative health disparities that plague black people today as a societal fate. The descendants of enslaved people lived much more dangerous and unhealthy lives than white counterparts, on disease-ridden and degraded environments. Within the confines of a segregated health-care system, these factors became poor health outcomes that shaped black America as if they were its genetic material.
https://twitter.com/time4equity/status/1175080469425266688?s=20
R.A.HahnaB.I.TrumanbD.R.Williamsc.Civil rights as determinants of public health and racial and ethnic health equity: Health care, education, employment, and housing in the United States.
SSM – Population Health: Volume 4, April 2018, Pages 17-24
Highlights
- Civil rights are characterized as social determinants of health.
- Four domains in civil rights history since 1950 are explored in—health care, education, employment, and housing.
- Health care, education, employment show substantial benefits when civil rights are enforced.
- Housing shows an overall failure to enforce existing civil rights and persistent discrimination.
- Civil rights and their enforcement may be considered a powerful arena for public health theorizing, research, policy, and action.
For more articles on COVID-19 Please go to our Coronovirus Portal
https://pharmaceuticalintelligence.com/coronavirus-portal/
2012pharmaceutical
sjwilliamspa